(Cabinet Member with Special Responsibility Councillor Hamilton-Cox)
Report of Director for Economic Growth & Regeneration (report published on 19.10.22)
Minutes:
Cabinet Member with Special Responsibility Councillor Hamilton-Cox)
Cabinet received a report from the Director for Economic Growth & Regeneration to outline a proposal for the Council’s electricity contract for the next four years. The Council’s electricity contract was due to expire on March 31, 2023 and the report outlined the reasons why the contract should be renewed for a period of four years. The contract covered all the non-Council housing property portfolio, as well as some Council Housing properties.
The options, options analysis, including risk assessment and officer preferred option, were set out in the report as follows:
|
Option 1: Remain with current provider (Npower) for a short contract period whilst the Council investigates other supplier options. |
Option 2: Renew the electricity contract via the YPO and go with a standard electricity tariff |
Option 3: Renew the electricity contract via the YPO and go with a REGO backed electricity tariff |
Advantages |
The Council will have completed its’ own tender process and have contractor control
Will allow the council the opportunity to identify if there are alternative suppliers who offer preferable rates/service |
YPO have already completed an evaluation of various suppliers before opting for Npower.
We will have continued support from YPO to help us address and solve any issues should they arise.
The YPO will provide annual fixed rates costs which will allow the council to budget accordingly. |
As Option 2
Additional REGO considerations:
Contributes to the council’s Carbon Zero agenda
Provides a guarantee electricity is from renewable energy sources e.g. wind farms.
Removes approx. 900 tCO2e (~20%) of the council’s Scope 1 and 2 carbon emissions |
Disadvantages |
Additional resource will be needed within the Council to carry out this work as current staffing levels and expertise in energy markets are not sufficient to do this.
The costs during the short period (likely one year) could increase above current rates if market conditions deteriorate further |
There hasn’t been an investigation into other options that might be available to us, i.e. other agents that may offer the same service as YPO. |
As Option 2
Additional REGO considerations:
There is an additional cost associated with the REGO. Costs will be confirmed once Npower have gone to market but current estimates are iro £73K per annum |
Risks |
This option has not been fully investigated so other advantages and disadvantages will be prevalent.
The council could fail to find a better provider and incur higher energy costs |
Other suppliers may offer preferable rates
Energy rates for the next financial year have yet to be confirmed |
As Option 2 Additional costs for the REGO have yet to be confirmed |
The officer preferred option is Option 3. Renewing the current approach to managing our electricity contracts provides a degree of confidence that would not otherwise be possible without incurring additional time and expense. This will also provide the maximum available security during a period of volatility in the energy market and allow for the council to continue towards its Zero Carbon agenda.
In accordance with the constitution the Chief Executive had consulted with the Chair of Overview & Scrutiny with regard to waiving call-in on Recommendation (1) in order that the completed contract could be returned to Npower before the end of October. Further details were contained in the Decision Notice to waive call-in appended to the minutes.
Councillor Hamilton-Cox proposed:
“That the recommendations, as set out in the report, be approved with a further recommendation ‘that Cabinet delegate authority to the Chief Executive to approve the award of contract with Npower, via the YPO, and to sign the same.”
Councillor Dowding seconded the recommendations and with the agreement of the meeting it was agreed that each of the recommendations should be voted on separately.
Cabinet voted on Recommendation (1) – (To renew the contract with Npower, via YPO, for four years) and agreed unanimously:
Resolved unanimously:
(1) That the contract with Npower, via YPO be renewed for four years.
Cabinet then voted on Recommendation (2) :- (To pay the additional rate for the Renewable Energy Guarantees of Origin (REGO) backed tariff in order to support the Council’s decision to be net zero carbon by 2030.)
Resolved:
(8 Members (Councillors Brookes, Dowding, Frea, Hamilton-Cox, Jackson (Caroline), Matthews, Thornberry & Wood) voted in favour, and 1 Member (Councillor Heath) voted against
(2) That approval be given to paying the additional rate for the Renewable Energy Guarantees of Origin (REGO) backed tariff in order to support the Council’s decision to be net zero carbon by 2030.
Cabinet then voted and agreed unanimously with the additional recommendation, Recommendation (3) – (that Cabinet delegate authority to the Chief Executive to approve the award of contract with Npower, via the YPO, and to sign the same.)
Resolved unanimously:
(3) That authority be delegated to the Chief Executive to approve the award of contract with Npower, via the YPO, and to sign the same.
Officers responsible for effecting the decision:
Chief Executive
Director for Economic Growth & Regeneration
Reasons for making the decision:
The decision is consistent with the council’s priorities most notably those associated with the Climate Emergency.
The agreement of a 4-year long-term energy contract with Npower, via the YPO procurement framework should provide benefit to the Council through the collaborative nature and involvement of other parties and afford a degree of certainty within our financial forecasts, in what is currently a very volatile area of significant expense to the Council.
Supporting documents: